Skip to main content
Comparison Guide 2025

SiteRoast vs PageSpeed Insights

Speed scores are just the beginning. Discover what PageSpeed Insights misses: security, UX, and conversion optimization.

Quick Answer: SiteRoast vs PageSpeed Insights

Google PageSpeed Insights measures website speed and Core Web Vitals (LCP, FID, CLS) with a score from 0-100. SiteRoast analyzes speed plus security vulnerabilities, UX/design quality, SEO health, and conversion optimization using 12 AI agents. Use PageSpeed for quick speed checks, SiteRoast for complete website audits.

Feature Comparison

Feature
SiteRoast
PageSpeed
Speed/Performance Score
Core Web Vitals + optimization tips
Core Web Vitals with score 0-100
Security Analysis
Full security audit (headers, SSL, OWASP)
Not included
Conversion Optimization
CTA analysis, user flow, friction points
Not included
SEO Analysis
Full SEO audit with E-E-A-T checks
~Links to Search Console only
Mobile vs Desktop
Unified analysis with mobile-first focus
Separate mobile/desktop tabs
Design/UX Feedback
Color, typography, layout analysis
Not included
Competitor Benchmarking
Compare against industry standards
Not included
Prioritized Action Items
AI-ranked by impact + code examples
~List of opportunities (no priority)
Security Blind Spots

PageSpeed gives you a 100 score even if your site is vulnerable. SiteRoast checks:

  • Security headers (CSP, HSTS, X-Content-Type)
  • SSL certificate issues
  • Information disclosure risks
  • Cookie security flags
Conversion Analysis

A fast site doesn't guarantee conversions. SiteRoast analyzes:

  • CTA visibility and placement
  • User friction points
  • Trust signals and social proof
  • Form usability
SEO Beyond Basics

PageSpeed links to Search Console. SiteRoast provides:

  • E-E-A-T signal analysis
  • Schema markup validation
  • Meta tag optimization
  • Internal linking analysis
Real User Experience

Speed metrics don't capture the full user experience:

  • Visual hierarchy effectiveness
  • Color contrast accessibility
  • Navigation clarity
  • Mobile touch target sizing

When to Use Each Tool

Use PageSpeed Insights When...
  • • You need a quick speed check
  • • Monitoring Core Web Vitals for Google ranking
  • • Debugging specific performance issues
  • • Comparing mobile vs desktop speed
Use SiteRoast When...
  • • You want a complete website audit
  • • Security is a concern
  • • Optimizing for conversions
  • • Getting actionable fixes with code
  • • Improving UX and design

Frequently Asked Questions

What does PageSpeed Insights not check?

PageSpeed Insights focuses only on performance metrics (Core Web Vitals, speed scores). It doesn't analyze security vulnerabilities, UX/design quality, conversion optimization, SEO beyond basics, or provide AI-powered recommendations.

Should I use PageSpeed Insights or SiteRoast?

Use both for different purposes. PageSpeed Insights is great for quick performance checks and Core Web Vitals. SiteRoast provides comprehensive analysis including security, design, UX, and AI-powered actionable insights that PageSpeed doesn't offer.

Why is my PageSpeed score different from SiteRoast?

Both tools measure Core Web Vitals, but SiteRoast's performance score also factors in security best practices and UX elements. A fast but insecure website will score lower on SiteRoast than PageSpeed.

Is a 100 PageSpeed score enough?

A 100 PageSpeed score means excellent performance, but it doesn't guarantee a secure, user-friendly, or high-converting website. SiteRoast analyzes all aspects that impact user experience and business results.

Go Beyond Speed Scores

Get security, UX, design, and conversion insights that PageSpeed doesn't provide. Free to start.